Salt & Stone Didn’t Work for You? Here’s What to Use Instead

If Salt & Stone didn’t work for your skin, you're definitely not the only one. A lot of people try natural deodorants hoping for something gentler, only to end up with redness, itchiness, or just plain body odor. If you've been searching for a natural deodorant that works and feels good on sensitive skin, we've got you covered. Here are a few gentle deodorant alternatives that actually do the job without making your skin angry.

Why Salt & Stone Might Not Work for Everyone

Salt & Stone makes popular natural deodorants. But like many other brands, it doesn’t work for everyone. Here’s why:

• Essential oils: These can smell great, but they often irritate sensitive skin.
• Baking soda: Common in natural deodorants, but it can throw off your skin’s pH and cause rashes.
• Too light or too strong: Some formulas don’t control odor well, while others are too aggressive.

If your underarms get red, itchy, or smelly by midday, it’s probably not your body’s fault. It’s just time to try a deodorant like Salt and Stone, but without the ingredients that cause problems. Let’s find one that works for you.

1. MAGS Skin Deodorant: Made for Sensitive Skin

MAGS Skin is a newer name in the game, but it’s quickly becoming a favorite for people with sensitive skin. If other brands made you break out or burn, this one feels like a relief.

Here’s what makes MAGS Skin deodorant different:

• No baking soda: So it won’t throw off your skin’s pH or cause irritation.
• Uses magnesium instead: Magnesium is odor-fighting. It's also skin-friendly.
• Simple, clean ingredients: No artificial fragrance or harsh chemicals.
• Goes on smooth: No sticky or greasy feeling.

It’s also a vegan deodorant that’s aluminum-free and cruelty-free. That makes it one of the best sensitive skin deodorant brands out there today. Plus, it actually works. Your skin stays calm. You stay fresh.

Best For:

Anyone who’s had a bad reaction to baking soda, or who wants a non-irritating natural deodorant that controls odor all day.

2. Native Sensitive Deodorant: A Cleaner Classic

Native is one of the most well-known names in natural deodorant. But if you’ve tried their regular formula and didn’t love it, don’t give up yet. Their sensitive line is made without baking soda and comes in gentler scents.

What’s good about it:

• Aluminum-free and baking soda-free
• Lightweight texture that absorbs quickly
• Vegan and cruelty-free

The sensitive formula still comes in fun scents like coconut vanilla or cotton & lily. But it won’t sting or dry out your skin like the original version might.

Best For:

People who liked the idea of Native but couldn’t handle the irritation. It’s a solid salt and stone alternative with a softer touch.

3. Each & Every Deodorant: Fragrance-Free and Effective

If scents tend to set your skin off, Each & Every makes a totally fragrance-free version. It’s easy on your skin and still stops odor fast.

Here’s what you’ll like:

• Made for sensitive skin with minimal ingredients
• Uses magnesium and dead sea salt to fight odor
• Certified vegan and EWG-verified

This one’s great if you want a natural deodorant that works and doesn’t compete with your perfume (or give you a headache).

Best For:

People who are sensitive to fragrance or want a truly clean, scent-free option. It’s one of the top vegan deodorant recommendations for a reason.

4. Type:A Sensitive Deodorant: Creamy but Dry

This one’s for you if you like a cream-style deodorant that dries quickly. Type:A uses a tube that squeezes out like lotion but applies easily with a built-in applicator.

What makes it stand out:

• Aluminum-free and baking soda-free
• Helps absorb sweat with natural powders
• Goes on creamy but dries matte

It’s another good aluminum free deodorant for sensitive skin, especially if you don’t like solids or sticks. And it comes in unscented and lightly scented versions.

Best For:

Anyone looking for a texture that’s smooth but not greasy. A great deodorant like Salt and Stone but with more skin-soothing power.

5. Meow Meow Tweet Baking Soda Free Deodorant Cream

Yes, the name is quirky. But this vegan brand makes one of the most gentle deodorants out there. It’s a creamy formula that comes in a jar. You apply it with your fingers kind of like a skincare product.

Why it works:

• Uses arrowroot and magnesium for odor control
• No baking soda, no synthetic fragrance
• Packaged in eco-friendly glass jars

This one’s perfect for people who want a more natural, hands-on approach. It’s a favorite among sensitive skin deodorant brands for a reason.

Best For:

Anyone who doesn’t mind using their hands and wants a super clean, skin-safe formula.

Quick Takeaways

• If Salt & Stone didn’t work: It’s likely due to baking soda or essential oils.
• Look for magnesium-based formulas: They fight odor without messing up your skin.
• MAGS Skin deodorant: Top pick for a non-irritating natural deodorant.
• Other great brands: Native Sensitive, Each & Every, Type:A, Meow Meow Tweet.

Final Thoughts

Finding the best deodorant for sensitive skin doesn’t have to mean giving up on staying fresh. You just need the right formula that’s gentle and effective. If Salt & Stone left you disappointed, don’t worry. There are better options out there.

MAGS Skin stands out as a smart switch. It’s clean, simple, and actually works. And it won’t make your skin feel like it’s under attack. That’s what a gentle deodorant alternative should do keep you comfortable and confident.

Your skin deserves better. And now you know where to start.